Free Market Foundation
The Free Market Foundation (FMF) is a right-wing libertarian think tank, founded in 1975, which has a history of working on behalf of the tobacco industry.
- 1 Background
- 2 Relationship with the Tobacco Industry
- 3 Pro-Tobacco Activities
- 4 TobaccoTactics Resources
- 5 Relevant Link
- 6 Notes
In 2017, FMF and Atlas co-hosted the Africa Liberty Forum, an annual event that promotes greater freedom in public policy in the African region.
FMF’s Executive Director Leon Louw and FMF staff and advisors have long been affiliated with the Mont Pelerin Society, an international organisation consisting of influential people who embrace free market principles. Other Mont Pelerin members include Dr Tim Evans and the Eamonn Butler from the Adam Smith Institute.
Relationship with the Tobacco Industry
Part-Funded by Tobacco Companies
British American Tobacco South Africa (BATSA), which holds about 74% of the South African cigarette market, has been a “senior corporate member” of FMF from 2000. Philip Morris International (PMI) was also listed on FMF’s website as a senior corporate member in 2013. Shortly after, the FMF removed information about members from its website, and it no longer makes its donors’ details public.
A statement on FMF’s website outlines the relationship between FMF and its members:
- “the FMF is employed by members to promote a market economy in which they earn higher profits.”
Furthermore, its role is to “assist business” by “making representations on behalf of its members to the government.”
Relationship with “Tobacco Kingpin” Johann Rupert
FMF has a long-standing relationship with the Rupert family of South Africa, who established the tobacco company Voorbrand in the 1940s, which was later consolidated with Rothmans International, before merging with British American Tobacco (BAT) to form BATSA. After this restructuring, Johann Rupert, described by some as South Africa’s “tobacco kingpin”, became Chairman of investment companies Remgro and Reinet, each of which has had a major shareholding in BAT.
Johann Rupert and his father Anton have been patrons of FMF between at least 2000 and 2016. FMF’s Louw has reported that in 2016 Johann Rupert “donated millions” to the FMF Khaya Lam project.
One of FMF’s objectives is “persuading the general public and consumer associations that government does not solve problems”. FMF staff and advisors have a long history of opposing tobacco control measures, criticising health research that threatens tobacco industry profits, and using national media outlets to voice their arguments.
Opposed South Africa’s 2018 Draft Tobacco Control Bill
In May 2018 the Government of South Africa announced its intention to introduce the Control of Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Bill, aimed at strengthening the country's tobacco legislation. The Bill proposed several measures strongly opposed by the tobacco industry, including Plain Packaging.
In response to the draft Bill, FMF’s Executive Director Louw has made various unsubstantiated claims in the media, including that the Bill is “anti-small business”, “unconstitutional”, and “ignores the mental health benefits of smoking”. Louw has further claimed that the draft Bill is an “assault on human dignity”, is “racist”, and will “threaten jobs and the economy”.
A peer-reviewed study from Bath University researchers has found that some of these misleading arguments have been used repeatedly by the tobacco industry in opposition to tobacco control measures. The study also showed that having its anti-legislation arguments voiced by more credible allies, like FMF, is a well-documented tobacco industry tactic to lobby governments and sway public opinion in favour of de-regulation.
- For more information on the tobacco industry’s opposition to South Africa's draft Bill, including the arguments and tactics used, go to South Africa: Industry Interference with the Control of Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Bill.
FMF Advisor Labelled World Bank Health Report “Wicked and Shameful”
In response to the World Bank’s 1999 report Curbing the Epidemic, which found tobacco control resulted in public health benefits without harming economies, tobacco companies recruited academics to write reports discrediting this evidence.
FMF lists two of these reports on its website under 'Our History' (key milestones and publications timeline).
The first, Smoked Out: Anti-Tobacco Activism at the World Bank published in 2000, appears to have been a joint effort between FMF and Hugh High from the IEA. Deepak Lal, a FMF Advisor between at least 2000 and 2018 wrote the preface to the report, in which he labelled concerns about passive smoking as a “false scare” and claimed tobacco control would damage poorer countries’ economic wellbeing. The report was cited approvingly in internal BAT documents.
The second report, Smoke gets in your eyes: The economic welfare effects of the World Bank-World Health Organisation global crusade against tobacco, was also published in 2000. It was co-written by Deepak Lal who describes the World Bank’s report as “wicked and shameful”. Lal claimed that tobacco control was simply “political correctness” and argued that for many “poor people”, smoking was “one of the only sources of pleasure in lives which remain ‘nasty, brutish and short’”.
Defender of Tobacco Marketing
Internal tobacco industry documents identify FMF as an organisation that helped protect the tobacco industry’s “marketing freedoms”.
For instance, in 1993 BAT carried out a survey of its global public affairs employees, who were asked to: “List the third party groups which have helped in the defence of your marketing freedoms (eg. advertisers, media, etc)”. FMF was one of a small number of organisations listed for South Africa. In a 1996 BAT document, an employee who had visited the United Tobacco Company (a company later acquired by BATSA), reported that United Tobacco Company were members of FMF because FMF helped protect against “legislative interference in marketing of products.”
These documents indicate FMF worked on behalf of BAT to try and block attempts to restrict tobacco marketing.
In 2016, FMF was one of 47 think tanks that collectively wrote to the World Health Organization to oppose plain packaging for tobacco products. Many of the other think tanks were affiliated with the Atlas Network.
- South Africa- Country Profile
- South Africa: Industry Interference with the Control of Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Bill
- Africa's Tobacco Epidemic
- British American Tobacco in Africa: A Past and Present of Double Standards
- Atlas Network
- Institute of Economic Affairs
- Philip Morris International
- British American Tobacco
- Atlas Network, Global Directory Africa, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, History, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, 1995 Mont Pelerin Society Regional Meeting – Cape Town, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Unknown, List of Attendees: Special Gathering Mont Pelerin, Switzerland April 9-12, 1997, accessed September 2018
- Euromonitor International, Cigarettes in South Africa. July 2017
- Free Market Foundation, Who we are, 2000, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Who we are, 2004, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Members, 2007, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Members, 2011, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Members, 2013, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Who We Are, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Support Use, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Become a Corporate Member or Donor, 2018, accessed September 2018
- The South African Free Market Foundation, Introducing the South African Free Market Foundation, 1 December 1975, accessed September 2018
- W. Stassen, New smoking laws to serve majority of South Africans, The Star, 31 July 2012, accessed September 2018
- BATSA, Our South African History, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Remgro Limited, Company History, 2018, accessed September 2018
- M. Hasenfuss, The three faces of Johann Rupert, “Fin24”, 1 July 2010, accessed September 2018
- Reinet Investments SCA, Reinet proposes revision to the terms of its prospectus, 24 January 2012, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Who we are, 2000, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, About Us, 2016, accessed September 2018
- L. Louw, Rupert’s actions his best reply to critics, Business Day, 30 March 2016, accessed September 2018
- C.O. Egbe, How South Africa is tightening its tobacco rules, The Conversation, 31 May 2018, accessed September 2018
- S. Gumada, Free Market Foundation fumes over proposed public smoking ban, The Citizen, 3 May 2018, accessed September 2018
- N. Motloung, Proposed new tobacco laws predicted to ‘go up in smoke’, Jacarandafm, 8 May 2018, accessed September 2018
- P. Phakgadi, Tobacco and electronic delivery systems slammed, Eyewitness News, undated, accessed September 2018
- C.J. Okoye, Last days to comment on ‘outrageous’ draft smoking bill, The Citizen, 7 August 2018, accessed September 2018
- F. Collins, Foundation fired up by ‘racist’ proposed tobacco bill, Times LIVE, 4 May 2018, accessed September 2018
- S. Ulucanlar, G.J. Fooks, A.B. Gilmore, The Policy Dystopia Model: An Interpretive Analysis of Tobacco Industry Political Activity, PLoS Medicine, 2016, 13(9):e1002125
- S. Glantz, H.M. Mamudu, R. Hammond, Tobacco Industry attempts to counter the World Bank Report Curbing the Epidemic and obstruct the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, Social Science & Medicine, 2008, 67(11):1690-1699
- Free Market Foundation, Our History, 2018, accessed September 2018
- R. Tren, H. High, Smoked out: Anti-Tobacco Activism at the World Bank, 2000, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, Who we are: Patrons, Council, Academic Advisors, Committees, 2000, accessed September 2018
- Free Market Foundation, President, Academic Advisors, Rule of Law Advisory Board, 2018, accessed September 2018
- Unknown, WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Q&As (not for external publication), 9 March 2000, Truth Tobacco Industry Documents, Bates no: 325035614-325035620, accessed September 2018
- R. Scruton, D. Lal, War on Tobacco: At What Cost?, 2000, Truth Tobacco Industry Documents, Bates no: 321331276-321331319, accessed September 2018
- Unknown, Science & Regulation Forecast, 16 September 1999, Truth Tobacco Industry Documents, Bates no: 325049951-325049964, accessed September 2018
- B. Brady, Public Affairs Review 1993, 25 May 1993, Truth Tobacco Industry Documents, Bates no: 500888155-500888336, accessed September 2018
- Unknown, Report on Visit to United Tobacco Company (UTC) – South Africa, 17 March 1996, Truth Tobacco Industry Documents, Bates no: 700570893-700570898, accessed September 2018
- R. Ullah, G.G. Norquist, L.B. Nelson et al., International Coalition Letter Against Plain Packaging, undated, accessed September 2018